The best use case for Stamped Loyalty in 2026 is Shopify brands already running Stamped Reviews who want to add a loyalty layer without switching vendors. Stamped Loyalty is a reviews-bundled loyalty module for Shopify, earning strong ratings from a large merchant base. Stamped sells its platform products (Loyalty, Reviews, and Lifecycle) separately, with plans available as single-product subscriptions or combined into a multi-product plan. For brands where loyalty is the primary revenue driver, it is worth understanding what the platform includes and where purpose-built retention platforms offer greater depth.
This review covers every loyalty feature, the current pricing structure, what Stamped does well, who it serves best, and how it compares to Rivo for brands building retention as a primary growth lever.
Stamped Loyalty is a strong choice for Shopify brands already on Stamped Reviews who want a loyalty layer inside the same platform, and for consumable product brands where the lifecycle automation adds meaningful repurchase support. Stamped's pricing page shows plans starting at $199/month for a single product and $798/month for multi-product access, with pricing varying by monthly order volume. Verify current pricing and trial availability directly with Stamped before budgeting. For Shopify brands where loyalty is the primary CLV driver, Rivo delivers greater checkout integration depth, paid memberships, and 8 checkout extensions starting at $49+/month.
Key Takeaways
- Stamped positions its platform around three products (Lifecycle, Loyalty, and Reviews), each available as a standalone subscription or combined into a multi-product plan.
- Stamped's pricing page states plans start at $199/month for a single product and $798/month for multi-product access, with pricing based on monthly order volume. Confirm current pricing and plan details directly on Stamped's pricing page.
- Stamped Loyalty includes points and rewards, VIP tiers, referrals, and review-triggered earning actions as core features.
- The native connection between Stamped Reviews and Stamped Loyalty, where review submissions automatically trigger point awards, is the platform's most distinctive differentiator.
- Stamped does not support subscription-based paid memberships at any tier.
- For Shopify brands prioritizing customer lifetime value through paid memberships and deep checkout integration, Rivo delivers greater retention depth at $49+/month with 8 checkout extensions and month-to-month billing.
Why Merchants Research Stamped Loyalty in 2026
Most merchants arrive at this review from one of three starting points.
- Evaluating the loyalty module within an existing Stamped relationship. Stamped is well-established in the reviews category, with a 4.7/5 rating across 3,649 Shopify App Store reviews. Brands already using Stamped Reviews evaluate the loyalty module as an extension of a vendor relationship they have already built.
- Looking for reviews-plus-loyalty consolidation. Merchants who want both review collection and loyalty mechanics managed from a single dashboard, with shared data and one support relationship, research Stamped as a consolidation option.
- Assessing fit as loyalty becomes a primary strategy. Brands that began with reviews and are expanding into loyalty as a primary retention driver want to know whether Stamped's loyalty capabilities match a more dedicated program roadmap, or whether a purpose-built platform is the better fit at that stage.
Understanding which situation applies to your store is a good way to get value from this review.
What Is Stamped Loyalty?
Stamped Loyalty is the loyalty and referral module within Stamped's ecommerce marketing platform for Shopify. It enables points-based rewards, VIP tier programs, referral campaigns, and review-triggered earning actions, all managed within a Stamped subscription that also covers reviews, UGC, and lifecycle automation tools.
Stamped sells Loyalty, Reviews, and Lifecycle as separate products. Merchants can subscribe to one product or combine multiple products into a multi-product plan. The platform's core identity is reviews-first: Stamped built its install base through review collection, UGC, and Google Shopping integration, with Loyalty positioned as a retention extension within that broader product suite.
The platform's most distinctive capability is the native data connection between its reviews product and the loyalty module. Review submission and approval trigger point awards automatically, without requiring custom workflows or third-party automation tools. For brands already running Stamped Reviews, this creates a feedback loop that simultaneously drives review volume and loyalty program engagement.
Stamped Loyalty at a Glance
- Shopify App Store Rating: 4.7/5 (3,649 reviews)
- G2 Rating: 4.6/5 (27 reviews)
- Products: Loyalty, Reviews, Lifecycle (sold separately or combined)
- Pricing: Starts at $199/month for a single product; $798/month for multi-product access (pricing varies by order volume; see Stamped's pricing page for current rates)
- Free Trial: Not mentioned on Stamped's pricing page; confirm availability directly with Stamped
- Platform: Shopify-compatible
Key Strengths
- Native reviews-plus-loyalty integration: review submissions automatically trigger point awards without custom workflows
- In-email review submission experience that drives higher review completion rates
- Lifecycle automation for consumable product categories with predictable repurchase cycles
- 4.7/5 rating across 3,649 Shopify App Store reviews reflecting strong overall satisfaction
- Single dashboard for reviews, UGC, loyalty, and lifecycle automation for brands wanting consolidation
Best For: Shopify brands already using Stamped Reviews who want a loyalty layer within the same platform, and consumable product brands where lifecycle replenishment automation adds meaningful retention value alongside a points program.
Stamped Loyalty Core Features
Points and Earning Rules
Stamped Loyalty supports multiple earning triggers beyond purchases. Customers accumulate points for writing product reviews, submitting photo reviews, uploading video UGC, following social accounts, completing birthday entries, signing up for accounts, and referring friends. Each action carries a configurable point value, letting merchants prioritize the behaviors most valuable to their program goals.
Earning multipliers are available for specific periods, such as promotional windows or launch campaigns, and for specific customer segments. The rules interface lets merchants build earning logic that reflects their product category, whether that means heavier weighting on repurchase actions for a consumables brand or review bonuses for a brand building UGC assets.
Redemption options cover percentage discounts, fixed amount discounts, free shipping rewards, and specific product redemptions. Merchants configure minimum point thresholds before redemption activates and point expiration terms to manage program economics.
VIP Tiers
Stamped's VIP tier system lets merchants define tier names, qualification thresholds, and tier-specific benefits, including earning rate multipliers, early product access, exclusive discount rates, and dedicated support designations. Tier qualification criteria include total lifetime points earned, total cumulative spend, or order count.
The on-site loyalty widget displays each customer's current tier and their progress toward the next one. Automated emails trigger at tier upgrades and when customers approach a new tier threshold, using Stamped's built-in communication templates.
Tier downgrade policies are configurable: merchants choose whether customers maintain tier status permanently, lose it at year’s end, or on a rolling 12-month basis, based on program objectives.
Referral Program
Stamped's referral module handles both sides of the referral transaction. Merchants configure advocate rewards (points awarded when a referred friend makes their first purchase), friend incentives (typically a first-purchase discount code), attribution tracking, and referral program terms covering minimum order values and eligible products.
The referral program shares infrastructure with Stamped's email and SMS communication tools. Referral invitation emails, friend reminder sequences, and advocate reward notifications go through the same platform handling review requests and loyalty communications. The dashboard aggregates referral performance data alongside reviews and loyalty metrics.
Reviews and Loyalty Integration
Stamped's tightest differentiator is the native connection between its review product and the loyalty module. Review submission and approval trigger point awards automatically, without custom workflows or third-party tools. Photo reviews earn higher point values than text-only reviews, and video UGC carries the highest earning multiplier, incentivizing the content types with the most marketing value.
Stamped's in-email review submission experience, where customers submit their review directly from the review request email without navigating to a separate page, reduces submission friction and drives higher review completion rates. Higher review volume feeds the loyalty program's earning activity: more reviews submitted means more points awarded, which increases program engagement.
Lifecycle Automation
Stamped includes a lifecycle replenishment system that estimates when individual customers are likely to run out of a purchased product and times outreach accordingly. Rather than sending replenishment emails on a fixed schedule, the system uses each customer's purchase history to calibrate timing individually.
This feature is most effective for consumable product categories: supplements, skincare, pet food, coffee, candles, and personal care products where reorder cycles are predictable. A customer who purchases a 30-day supplement supply receives a replenishment communication timed to approximately day 25 of their cycle. That timing precision generates higher open and conversion rates than generic win-back sequences.
Stamped Loyalty Analytics and Reporting
Stamped's dashboard aggregates referral performance, points activity, tier distribution, and review collection metrics in a single reporting view. Merchants can monitor which earning actions drive the most program participation, which redemption types are most popular, and how tier distribution maps against the total customer base.
The consolidated reporting covers the core program health questions: Are customers earning points? Are they redeeming? Is the referral program converting? For brands using both Reviews and Loyalty, the shared dashboard eliminates the need to switch between tools to understand the full picture of content and retention activity.
For brands using analytics to drive deep retention strategy iteration, including cohort-level CLV analysis or attribution modeling over extended windows, dedicated retention platforms offer greater analytical depth at comparable price points.
Stamped Loyalty Integrations
Stamped connects with a range of ecommerce tools supporting its reviews, loyalty, and lifecycle products.
Email and SMS
- Klaviyo, Omnisend, and others (shared across Reviews and Loyalty products)
Reviews
- Google Shopping integration for seller ratings and product reviews
Helpdesk
- Gorgias and others
Shopify-native
- Shopify Checkout, Shopify POS, Shopify Flow, Shopify Admin
Checkout-level loyalty functionality: Stamped does not publicly list a Shopify checkout extension count on its website. Verify checkout-level functionality and integration depth directly with Stamped before purchasing.
For context, Rivo's 50+ integrations include Klaviyo, Attentive, Recharge, Gorgias, Okendo, and others across standard plans, and Rivo explicitly lists 8 checkout extensions on its pricing page.
Stamped Loyalty Pricing: Plan Summary
Stamped prices its platform products (Loyalty, Reviews, and Lifecycle) separately. Merchants can subscribe to one product or combine multiple products into a multi-product plan. Pricing is based on (a) which products are included and (b) monthly order volume.
Per Stamped's pricing page:
- Single-product plans start at $199/month
- Multi-product access starts at $798/month
- Loyalty is shown at $299/month at the selected example order volume on Stamped's pricing page
- Reviews is shown at $199/month at the selected example order volume
- Lifecycle is shown at $499/month at the selected example order volume
These prices vary based on monthly order volume using a selector on Stamped's pricing page. Confirm current pricing, product packaging, and available trial or evaluation options directly on Stamped's pricing page before budgeting, as rates are based on order volume and subject to change.
Annual billing is available and carries a discount versus monthly billing. Confirm discount terms and contract length directly with Stamped.
Stamped Loyalty Customer Support
Stamped's support quality is one of the consistently cited strengths in Shopify App Store reviews. Merchants across tiers note responsive support during initial setup and troubleshooting.
- Standard plans access email and chat support. Reviewers frequently cite resolution times and support quality that exceed expectations for the price point.
- Enterprise includes a dedicated account manager and custom SLA commitments.
G2 reviewers at 4.6/5 across 27 reviews reflect a smaller but broadly positive picture of enterprise and mid-market experience with the platform. Reviews that specifically address the loyalty module note that the reviews-to-loyalty integration works as described, with review submissions consistently triggering point awards.
Who Stamped Loyalty Is Best For
Stamped Loyalty fits specific merchant profiles better than most alternatives in the category.
Brands Already Using Stamped Reviews
The strongest argument for Stamped Loyalty is ecosystem continuity. If a store already uses Stamped for reviews, UGC, and Google Shopping integration, adding the loyalty module keeps both functions in one platform, one data model, and one vendor relationship. The integration value is immediate and operational, with review submissions feeding directly into loyalty point awards without any additional configuration.
Consumable Product Categories
Brands selling supplements, skincare, pet food, coffee, candles, or other products with predictable repurchase cycles get the most out of Stamped's lifecycle automation. The combination of replenishment timing and points-for-reviews creates a retention engine suited to high-frequency, replenishment-driven categories.
Brands Where Reviews Drive the Primary Marketing Strategy
If a store's growth strategy centers on review volume, Google Shopping performance, and UGC content rather than deep loyalty program mechanics, Stamped's product architecture aligns with those priorities. The loyalty module enhances a reviews-first strategy without requiring loyalty-specific expertise or a separate platform investment.
Multi-Tool Consolidation for Reviews and Loyalty
Merchants who currently manage separate apps for review collection and loyalty programs and want to consolidate both into one subscription and dashboard find Stamped's bundled approach removes real operational overhead.
Rivo: The Shopify-Native Alternative
For Shopify brands where customer lifetime value is a primary strategic metric and loyalty is the core retention driver, Rivo warrants direct comparison alongside Stamped Loyalty. Rivo is a retention platform built exclusively for Shopify, combining loyalty, referrals, paid memberships, and personalized customer accounts in a single Shopify-native system.
Rivo at a Glance
- Merchants: 9,000+ Shopify brands
- Shopify App Store Rating: 4.8/5 (1,400+ reviews)
- Revenue Driven: $1.5B+ through platform
- Platform: Shopify-native (Shopify-exclusive)
- Plans: Free, Scale ($49+/mo), Plus ($499/mo), Enterprise (Custom)
- Billing: Month-to-month, no annual contract
Key Strengths
- VIP tiers, 50+ integrations, and unlimited earning rules from $49+/mo
- 8 checkout extensions (explicitly listed on Rivo's pricing page)
- Subscription-based paid memberships: the only Shopify retention platform with this capability built in
- Developer API toolkit with rate limits up to 100 per second, available from $499/mo
- Sub-100ms load times across all checkout extensions
- Fraud protection tools for referral programs
- Free white-glove migration for qualifying brands
- 52x weighted median ROI across 9,000+ Shopify brands
- 100% bootstrapped, month-to-month billing, no annual contract
Best For: Shopify brands where loyalty is the primary driver of customer lifetime value, including fast-growing DTC brands that want paid memberships, brands with complex VIP tier programs, and stores where checkout-level loyalty engagement is a priority.
Proof Points: HexClad generated 92x referral ROI ($450K in 90 days). OSEA achieved a 77% repeat purchase rate among loyalty redeemers. Fresh Chile Co saw a 156% AOV increase from paid memberships. BERO generated 1 billion impressions through Rivo's omnichannel membership capabilities.
Feature and Pricing Comparison
VIP tiers
- Stamped Loyalty: Included in Loyalty product; confirm plan gating with Stamped
- Rivo: from $49+/mo
Subscription-based paid memberships
- Stamped Loyalty: Not available
- Rivo: from $49+/mo
Checkout extensions
- Stamped Loyalty: Not publicly listed on Stamped's website; verify directly with Stamped
- Rivo: 8 (explicitly listed on Rivo's pricing page)
Starting price (loyalty)
- Stamped Loyalty: $199/mo single product (Loyalty shown at $299/mo at example volume on Stamped's pricing page; confirm current rates)
- Rivo: $49+/mo (Scale plan, 7-day free trial available)
Integrations
- Stamped Loyalty: Reviews, Klaviyo, Gorgias, Shopify-native tools; confirm full list with Stamped
- Rivo: 50+
Pricing model
- Stamped Loyalty: Order-volume based; annual billing available
- Rivo: Scale $49-$499/mo (200-2,500 orders); Plus $499/mo (up to 2,500 orders); Enterprise custom; month-to-month
Multi-product bundle
- Stamped Loyalty: Yes (Loyalty, Reviews, Lifecycle available separately or combined)
- Rivo: Loyalty-focused; reviews via integrations (Okendo, Stamped)
What Rivo Does Differently for Shopify Brands
- Subscription-based paid memberships, unique to Rivo. Rivo is the only Shopify retention platform where merchants charge customers a recurring fee for immediate access to exclusive loyalty benefits. Fresh Chile Co achieved a 156% AOV increase from paid memberships. BERO generated 1 billion impressions through Rivo's omnichannel membership program. Stamped Loyalty does not offer subscription-based paid memberships at any tier.
- 8 checkout extensions explicitly listed. Rivo's pricing page explicitly states "8 checkout extensions," capturing loyalty interactions at the moment of purchase. Stamped does not publicly list a checkout extension count on its website. For brands where checkout-level loyalty engagement is a strategic priority, Rivo's published checkout integration depth is a meaningful differentiator.
- VIP tiers from $49+/mo with a 7-day free trial. Rivo's Scale plan starts at $49+/mo and includes a 7-day free trial on its pricing page. Stamped's single-product Loyalty pricing starts at $199/mo (with Loyalty shown at $299/mo at the example volume on Stamped's pricing page). Verify current Stamped pricing directly, as rates vary by order volume.
- 50+ integrations at standard pricing. Rivo's integration ecosystem covers Klaviyo, Attentive, Recharge, Gorgias, Okendo, and 50+ tools across standard plans. Confirm Stamped's current integration list directly with Stamped for full coverage details.
- Fraud protection tools for referral programs. Rivo includes fraud protection tools for referral programs. Stamped's referral fraud protection specifics are not publicly enumerated on its website; verify directly with Stamped.
- Verified Shopify outcomes. The 52x weighted median ROI across Rivo's 9,000+ Shopify brands includes OSEA Malibu (77% repeat purchase rate among loyalty redeemers) and HexClad ($450K in referral revenue in 90 days). Rivo has driven $1.5B+ in total revenue through the platform.
- 100% bootstrapped, month-to-month. Rivo operates with no venture capital and no annual contract requirement. Pricing decisions reflect merchant value rather than investor return targets, and brands can upgrade, downgrade, or cancel at any billing cycle.
The Honest Tradeoff
Stamped's native reviews-to-loyalty integration is a genuine capability that Rivo does not replicate natively. When a customer submits a review through Stamped Reviews, points are automatically credited in Stamped Loyalty without a third-party connector. For brands that have spent years building their Stamped Reviews program, that shared data layer creates personalization and engagement opportunities that require custom integration work to reproduce elsewhere.
Stamped also carries a 4.7/5 rating across 3,649 reviews, a large established user base, and the operational advantage of combining reviews, UGC, and loyalty in a single billing and support relationship.
For brands where the primary loyalty goal is subscription-based paid memberships, explicitly published checkout integration depth, and a broad integration ecosystem at standard tiers, the comparison shifts toward Rivo.
Book a demo to see how Rivo's retention depth compares to Stamped Loyalty for your specific store and growth goals.
Stamped Loyalty Review: Final Verdict
Stamped Loyalty is a well-reviewed loyalty module with a genuine value proposition for brands already embedded in the Stamped ecosystem. Its 4.7/5 rating across 3,649 Shopify App Store reviews reflects consistent quality, particularly for brands where reviews and loyalty work together as a combined content and retention strategy.
The pricing structure requires direct verification before committing. Stamped's pricing page shows plans starting at $199/month for a single product and $798/month for multi-product access, with rates varying by monthly order volume. Confirm current plan details, feature gating, trial availability, and contract terms directly on Stamped's pricing page before budgeting.
Stamped Loyalty is worth it for:
- Brands already using Stamped Reviews who want a loyalty layer with native review-to-loyalty point automation in one platform
- Consumable product brands where the lifecycle replenishment automation adds meaningful, individually timed repurchase outreach
- Merchants whose primary marketing asset is review volume, Google Shopping performance, and UGC content rather than deep loyalty program mechanics
- Brands seeking to consolidate reviews and loyalty in one subscription and vendor relationship
Where alternatives warrant evaluation:
- Brands that need subscription-based paid memberships as a retention and recurring revenue layer (Stamped Loyalty does not offer this)
- Merchants who want explicitly published checkout extension depth at a lower entry price point
- Stores where loyalty is the primary growth driver and a purpose-built retention platform's feature velocity matters
- Brands that want month-to-month billing flexibility without an annual commitment
Bottom line: Stamped Loyalty is the right fit within a Stamped ecosystem for brands where reviews and loyalty work together. For Shopify brands where loyalty mechanics are the primary CLV driver, a direct comparison with a purpose-built retention platform is worth completing before committing.
See how Rivo compares on paid memberships, checkout extensions, and pricing at your order volume.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is Stamped Loyalty?
Stamped Loyalty is the loyalty and referral module within Stamped's ecommerce marketing platform for Shopify. It lets merchants build points-based reward programs, configure VIP tiers, run referral campaigns, and connect earning actions to review submissions and UGC contributions. Stamped sells Loyalty, Reviews, and Lifecycle as separate products that can be subscribed to individually or combined in a multi-product plan.
How Much Does Stamped Loyalty Cost in 2026?
Stamped's pricing page states plans start at $199/month for a single product and $798/month for multi-product access, with pricing based on monthly order volume. Loyalty is shown at $299/month at the selected example order volume on Stamped's pricing page. Confirm current pricing, plan details, and any available trial options directly on Stamped's pricing page before purchasing, as rates vary by order volume and are subject to change.
Does Stamped Loyalty Support Paid Memberships?
No. Stamped Loyalty does not offer subscription-based paid memberships, where customers pay a recurring fee for immediate access to exclusive loyalty benefits. This capability is unique to Rivo among Shopify loyalty platforms. Fresh Chile Co saw a 156% AOV increase using Rivo's paid membership feature.
How Does Stamped Loyalty Compare to Rivo?
Stamped Loyalty is best for brands already using Stamped Reviews who want a loyalty layer with native review-to-point integration and consolidated billing. Rivo is purpose-built for Shopify retention: VIP tiers from $49+/mo, subscription-based paid memberships (not available in Stamped), 8 checkout extensions explicitly listed on Rivo's pricing page, 50+ integrations, and month-to-month billing. For brands where loyalty is the primary CLV driver, Rivo's Shopify-native depth and explicitly published feature set offer a clearer benchmark for what you're getting before purchase.
Can I Migrate from Stamped Loyalty to Rivo?
Yes. Rivo offers free white-glove migration for qualifying Shopify brands, covering customer point balances, tier assignments, and referral histories so customers retain their complete loyalty standing without disruption. Contact Rivo directly to confirm eligibility and scope for your specific program.
