Loyalty Program Breakage & Redemption Rate Benchmarks by Industry

Learn how to calculate loyalty breakage and redemption rates, compare industry benchmarks, and track reward liabilities for better program performance.
November 17, 2026
Team Rivo
rivo.io

You pull three industry reports to benchmark your loyalty program's breakage rate. All three give different numbers, and none explains its methodology clearly enough to determine whether your program is performing well.

One source cites a breakage range of 5% to 30%. Another suggests 20% to 30% for retail. A third reports substantially higher levels in travel programs.

But the sources do not consistently disclose the age of the points being measured, the observation period, the treatment of promotional rewards, or whether the numbers represent actual expiration or expected future non-redemption.

Without that information, comparing the figures can be misleading.

Brands using retention dashboards, including Rivo's Analytics Home, need to distinguish between operational redemption activity, expected breakage, and the financial liability associated with outstanding rewards.

This guide explains how to calculate loyalty program breakage and redemption rates, what published industry figures can and cannot tell you, how accounting standards treat unredeemed rewards, and how to build more useful internal benchmarks.

Key Takeaways

  • There is no single authoritative breakage or redemption benchmark that applies across all loyalty programs and industries.
  • Published breakage ranges often come from loyalty vendors, trade publications, or analyses with limited methodological transparency.
  • Unredeemed points are not automatically broken points. Some remain valid and may be redeemed later.
  • Period redemption activity, cohort redemption rates, and ultimate redemption rates measure different things.
  • Under ASC 606 and IFRS 15, qualifying loyalty rewards may represent separate performance obligations that require deferred revenue recognition.
  • Expected breakage may be recognized proportionately when the relevant requirements are satisfied. Otherwise, recognition generally occurs when further redemption becomes remote.
  • An expected reward-cost estimate is not automatically equivalent to the contract liability reported under revenue-recognition accounting.
  • Point expiration, reward relevance, redemption thresholds, and member engagement can all affect breakage.
  • A program's historical results, segmented by comparable cohorts and consistently measured over time, provide a more defensible benchmark than unsupported industry averages.

What Loyalty Program Breakage Means

Breakage refers to loyalty rewards or customer rights that are never redeemed.

In a points-based program, this may include points that expire before customers use them.

In a cashback or store-credit program, it may involve balances that customers never redeem, subject to the program's terms and applicable laws.

The distinction between unredeemed and broken rewards is important.

Consider a customer who earns 1,000 points in October and has until the following October to redeem them.

If the customer still holds those points in December, the points are outstanding.

They have not necessarily become breakage because the customer may still redeem them.

Breakage can be measured retrospectively for mature reward cohorts or estimated prospectively for points that remain outstanding.

Milliman's loyalty analysis distinguishes ultimate breakage rate from ultimate redemption rate.

Ultimate breakage represents the proportion of a defined pool of points expected never to be redeemed.

Ultimate redemption represents the proportion expected to be used.

For the same defined point population, these two measures are complements.

A program with an expected ultimate redemption rate of 70% has an expected ultimate breakage rate of 30%.

However, these estimates are meaningful only when the underlying population and measurement assumptions are clearly defined.

A 30-day activity ratio should not be compared directly with an ultimate breakage estimate.

Breakage Rate Benchmarks by Industry

Published breakage estimates vary widely.

Some loyalty-platform analyses cite overall ranges of approximately 5% to 30%.

Other reports suggest breakage of around 20% to 30% for retail programs.

Historical trade publications have cited retail estimates near 25% and significantly higher estimates for some airline programs.

Other vendor analyses have published figures as high as 70% to 85% for selected travel or business-to-business reward arrangements.

These figures should not be treated as independently validated industry standards.

The central problem is comparability.

A retail program allowing customers to redeem points immediately may have a very different redemption pattern from an airline program requiring a large points balance for a flight.

Likewise, a program with points that never expire cannot be evaluated in the same way as one with a 30-day expiration period.

Even within the same industry, brands may differ in:

  • Reward availability.
  • Minimum redemption thresholds.
  • Point expiration policies.
  • Customer purchasing frequency.
  • Promotional point issuance.
  • Member demographics.
  • Program maturity.
  • Redemption channels.

Published percentages can provide historical context, but they should not be used as automatic performance targets.

A retailer reporting 35% breakage is not necessarily underperforming another retailer reporting 20%.

The difference may reflect program design, customer behavior, or incompatible measurement methods.

The more useful question is whether breakage is changing within a consistently measured program and what that change means for customer engagement and outstanding obligations.

Redemption Rate Benchmarks by Industry

Redemption measures how customers use the rewards they earn.

However, the term redemption rate can refer to several different calculations.

Some platforms measure the number of points redeemed during a reporting period divided by points earned during that same period.

Others calculate the percentage of rewards issued to a particular cohort that have been redeemed.

Financial forecasting models estimate the proportion of outstanding points expected to be redeemed eventually.

These are different measures and should not share a single benchmark.

For example, customers may redeem points earned months earlier.

If a store issues 100,000 points in June but customers redeem 120,000 points during June, the period redemption-to-issuance ratio is 120%.

That does not mean the program redeemed more than 100% of its total lifetime rewards.

It means the period's redemptions exceeded new issuance.

A cohort-based measure avoids this particular mismatch by tracking the same population of points from issuance to redemption or expiration.

Why Enrollment Statistics Are Not Redemption Benchmarks

Loyalty membership is widespread, but enrollment does not establish reward usage.

According to Forrester's research, 85% of US online adults belonged to at least one retail loyalty program in 2024.

Research from Boston Consulting Group found that the average US consumer belonged to more than 15 loyalty programs in 2024, approximately 10% more than in 2022.

These findings demonstrate widespread program adoption.

They do not establish how frequently points are redeemed.

A program can have high enrollment and low redemption, or a smaller membership base with substantial reward usage.

For that reason, participation figures should be evaluated separately from points issuance, redemption, and breakage.

How to Calculate Breakage and Redemption Rates

The correct formula depends on what the business wants to measure.

Ultimate Breakage Rate

For a fully matured issuance cohort, ultimate breakage can be calculated as:

Ultimate Breakage Rate = (Points never redeemed ÷ Total eligible points issued) × 100

For points that have not reached their final redemption outcome, businesses need to estimate the proportion that will never be used.

These estimates should account for observed redemption patterns, expiration dates, and remaining customer rights.

Ultimate Redemption Rate

For the same cohort:

Ultimate Redemption Rate = (Points ultimately redeemed ÷ Total eligible points issued) × 100

When every point has either been redeemed or permanently forfeited, ultimate redemption and ultimate breakage should total 100%, assuming the same scope and no unresolved adjustments.

Period Redemption Activity

An operational activity ratio can be calculated as:

Period Redemption Activity = (Points redeemed during period ÷ Points issued during period) × 100

This measure compares activity flows during a reporting period.

It may exceed 100% because customers can redeem points earned in previous periods.

It should not be presented as the ultimate redemption rate.

Cohort Redemption Rate

For a defined issuance cohort:

Cohort Redemption Rate = (Cohort points redeemed to date ÷ Cohort points originally issued) × 100

This measures how much of a specific point population has been redeemed by the observation date.

For immature cohorts, the remainder is not necessarily breakage.

Some points may still be outstanding and redeemable.

Reward-Usage Rate

Programs may also measure the percentage of available reward certificates or eligible members that complete a redemption.

For example:

Reward-Usage Rate = (Reward certificates redeemed ÷ Reward certificates issued) × 100

This is a certificate-level metric rather than a point-value metric.

A program should disclose whether partial redemptions count as completed redemptions.

These distinctions matter because changing the denominator can substantially change the reported result.

Point Liability and the Accounting Treatment of Unredeemed Points

Loyalty rewards can create obligations that require financial reporting.

However, not every points promotion has the same accounting treatment.

Under ASC 606 and IFRS 15, loyalty points that give customers a material right to future goods or services generally represent a separate performance obligation.

When that condition is met, the business allocates part of the transaction price to the loyalty obligation based on relative standalone selling prices.

That amount is generally deferred until the relevant obligation is satisfied or revenue can otherwise be recognized under the applicable guidance.

The liability is not necessarily calculated using only the expected cost of providing rewards.

Expected Reward Cost Versus Contract Liability

Milliman provides a simplified model for estimating the future cost associated with outstanding loyalty points:

Expected Reward Cost = Cost per Point × Outstanding Points × Expected Ultimate Redemption Rate

Since ultimate redemption rate is the complement of ultimate breakage, this can also be expressed as:

Expected Reward Cost = Cost per Point × Outstanding Points × (1 − Ultimate Breakage Rate)

This is a useful actuarial estimate.

However, it should not automatically be treated as the contract liability recognized under ASC 606 or IFRS 15.

Financial reporting may require allocating transaction consideration to a material right, rather than simply recognizing the expected cost of fulfilling rewards.

The appropriate method depends on the program structure and accounting requirements.

When Can Breakage Be Recognized as Revenue?

Under IFRS 15, a business that expects to be entitled to breakage and satisfies the relevant requirements generally recognizes expected breakage in proportion to customers' exercise of their rights.

If the business does not expect to be entitled to breakage under those requirements, recognition generally occurs when the likelihood of customers exercising their remaining rights becomes remote.

A further exception applies when unclaimed amounts must be remitted to another party, such as a government under applicable unclaimed-property laws.

Those amounts must be treated as liabilities rather than automatically recognized as breakage revenue.

Businesses should evaluate loyalty accounting with qualified accounting professionals.

How Expiration, Dormancy, and Reward Design Affect Breakage

Expiration policies can influence both redemption behavior and expected breakage.

When points expire quickly, customers have less time to accumulate and use rewards.

A short expiration period may encourage some members to redeem sooner.

However, it can also cause rewards to expire before other customers have a practical opportunity to use them.

Expiration is only one influence on breakage.

Other important factors include:

  • Minimum redemption thresholds.
  • Reward catalog relevance.
  • Customer purchase frequency.
  • Ease of redeeming rewards.
  • Reward communication.
  • Product availability.
  • Program participation requirements.
  • Customer account activity.

Redemption Friction

Redemption friction occurs when members encounter barriers to using earned rewards.

Examples include complicated redemption procedures, high minimum balances, confusing eligibility rules, or limited redemption options.

These barriers can leave points outstanding or increase eventual breakage.

Industry practitioners have warned that high breakage may indicate problems with a program's reward experience.

For example, guidance from the Incentive Marketing Association discusses the relationship between breakage, reward accessibility, and engagement.

However, high breakage does not automatically establish that a program is poorly designed.

A valid interpretation requires examining the underlying causes.

Why Expiration Mechanics Matter

Programs can use different expiration structures.

Some expire points a fixed number of months after issuance.

Others reset expiration following qualifying activity.

Some apply expiration rules to individual earning transactions, while others use account-level or balance-level policies.

These structures can produce different outcomes even when the underlying customer behavior is similar.

Businesses should document their expiration settings and account for policy changes when analyzing breakage trends.

How to Forecast Breakage Without Overstating Revenue

Breakage forecasting requires estimating how much of an outstanding reward balance will ultimately be redeemed.

This estimate affects expected reward costs and may influence revenue recognition or liability measurement, depending on the accounting arrangement.

Overestimating breakage can understate expected future redemption obligations.

Underestimating breakage can overstate expected reward costs or liabilities in some models.

However, financial-reporting consequences depend on the applicable accounting method.

Forecasts should be developed using actual program activity rather than a generic industry percentage whenever possible.

A practical forecasting process includes:

  • Reviewing historical redemption patterns.
  • Tracking cohorts according to when points were issued.
  • Separating ordinary earned points from promotional rewards.
  • Monitoring expiration and forfeiture events.
  • Evaluating different customer segments.
  • Updating assumptions as actual redemption outcomes become available.

Businesses should review material assumptions at financial reporting dates and apply changes according to the relevant accounting guidance.

Forecasts should also account for changes in program rules.

If a merchant extends point validity from six months to 12 months, historical redemption patterns may no longer provide a reliable estimate without adjustment.

Similarly, introducing a lower redemption threshold may change how quickly members use their rewards.

A Benchmarking Framework: Cohort, Time Window, and Denominator

A useful benchmark starts with consistent definitions.

Before comparing two loyalty program metrics, brands should establish four factors.

Cohort Age

A cohort consists of rewards issued during a defined period or to a defined customer group.

Points issued three months ago should not be compared directly with points issued several years ago if their redemption opportunities differ.

For example, a 90-day-old cohort may still have most of its points available.

A mature cohort with expired rewards provides a clearer picture of ultimate breakage.

Observation Window

The observation window defines the period over which activity is measured.

A rolling 30-day redemption ratio measures recent activity.

An ultimate redemption estimate projects how much of a defined point population will eventually be redeemed.

These numbers answer different questions.

Denominator

The denominator establishes what the metric is being compared against.

Common denominator choices include:

  • Points issued.
  • Points outstanding.
  • Reward certificates issued.
  • Eligible customers.
  • Active members.
  • Points earned during a reporting period.

Brands should use the same denominator when comparing performance across periods.

Scope

Scope determines which points or rewards are included.

For example, standard transaction points may have different earning and expiration characteristics from promotional bonuses.

Combining all points into one figure can hide important changes in customer behavior.

Separate reporting can help merchants identify which program components contribute to higher or lower redemption.

Examples of Breakage and Liability Calculations

Worked examples help illustrate why operational and accounting calculations should be kept separate.

Example 1: Calculating Ultimate Breakage

Suppose a retailer issues one million points to a cohort.

After the cohort reaches its final redemption outcome:

  • 700,000 points have been redeemed.
  • 300,000 points have permanently expired or otherwise become unusable.

The ultimate redemption rate is:

700,000 ÷ 1,000,000 × 100 = 70%

The ultimate breakage rate is:

300,000 ÷ 1,000,000 × 100 = 30%

These two figures are complements because the cohort has reached its final outcome and all points are accounted for.

Example 2: Estimating Future Reward Costs

Suppose a retailer has 10 million outstanding points.

The company estimates that 65% of those points will eventually be redeemed.

Assume the expected fulfillment cost per redeemed point is $0.01.

The estimated future reward cost is:

10,000,000 × $0.01 × 65% = $65,000

This calculation follows the simplified expected-cost approach described by Milliman.

It is not automatically the ASC 606 contract liability.

The accounting liability may depend on the amount of transaction consideration allocated to the reward obligation.

Example 3: Revenue Recognition Under ASC 606

A standard example illustrates how qualifying loyalty points can create deferred revenue.

Assume a company sells $100,000 in products and issues 10,000 loyalty points.

The company expects 9,500 points to be redeemed.

The standalone selling price assigned to the points is $9,500.

Using relative standalone selling prices, the company allocates:

  • $91,324 to the products sold.
  • $8,676 to the loyalty points.

At the end of the reporting period, 4,500 points have been redeemed.

The company still expects 9,500 points to be redeemed eventually.

The loyalty-related revenue recognized is approximately:

$8,676 × (4,500 ÷ 9,500) = $4,110

The remaining contract liability is approximately:

$8,676 − $4,110 = $4,566

This calculation illustrates revenue recognition for a qualifying material-right arrangement.

It should not be confused with simply multiplying outstanding points by their estimated fulfillment cost.

How Rivo's Analytics Help Brands Track Redemption Performance

For Shopify brands, reliable loyalty reporting can help separate customer participation from actual business performance.

Rivo's Analytics Home includes metrics related to loyalty programs, referrals, customer accounts, revenue attribution, and program ROI.

According to Rivo's official documentation, the dashboard supports comparisons involving average order value, repeat purchase rates, purchase frequency, and customer lifetime value.

It also provides separate comparisons between loyalty redeemers and nonmembers, as well as account-enabled and account-disabled customers.

These comparisons can help merchants identify differences in customer behavior.

However, they should not automatically be interpreted as proof that loyalty participation caused a particular increase in spending.

Tracking Outstanding Rewards and Liability

Rivo also offers reporting for outstanding loyalty balances.

Its Outstanding Earnings Report allows merchants to review earning, spending, expiration, adjustments, and other balance activity.

Merchants can use these records to support internal reconciliation and financial analysis.

Rivo's liability guidance explains how merchants can estimate gross outstanding points value and consider expected redemption assumptions.

For example, if a merchant has 2,450,000 outstanding points worth $0.01 each, the gross reward value is $24,500.

Assuming an expected redemption rate of 62%, a simplified expected-value estimate would be $15,190.

This calculation can support financial planning, but the business and its accounting advisors remain responsible for determining the appropriate financial-statement treatment.

Rivo does not replace accounting or legal advice.

Understanding Rivo's ROI Metric

Rivo Analytics Home also reports revenue attributed to Rivo-powered programs and compares that amount with subscription costs.

Rivo uses 12.5x ROI as an illustrative example.

That represents $12.50 in attributed revenue for every $1 spent on Rivo subscription fees.

This is an example of how the metric is expressed, not a guaranteed or average result.

Attributed revenue should also be distinguished from incremental revenue.

Rivo Customer Results

Rivo's Kitsch case study reports more than $5.8 million in loyalty-attributed revenue.

It also reports that customers in Kitsch's highest VIP tier demonstrated an 8.7x higher repeat purchase rate.

These results describe customer activity and attributed revenue rather than the financial valuation of Kitsch's loyalty program.

The case study also reports more than one million reward redemptions across customer tiers.

This demonstrates how a brand can monitor program activity at scale, but it does not establish a universal breakage or redemption benchmark.

For merchants, the most useful approach is to combine platform reporting with consistently defined internal metrics, historical cohort analysis, and appropriate financial reconciliation.

Final Thoughts

Loyalty program breakage and redemption rates are useful metrics, but only when their definitions and measurement periods are clear.

A percentage of points that remain unredeemed today is not necessarily the same as the percentage that will never be redeemed.

Likewise, a monthly redemption activity ratio should not be compared directly with an ultimate redemption estimate.

Industry figures can provide context, but many published ranges lack the transparency needed to support meaningful comparisons.

Brands should prioritize their own historical performance, measured across comparable cohorts and consistent reporting periods.

They should also separate operational reward metrics from financial accounting estimates.

ASC 606 and IFRS 15 can require deferred revenue recognition for loyalty awards that create material rights, while expected breakage is recognized according to the applicable requirements.

For Shopify merchants, tools such as Rivo can support loyalty analytics and outstanding-balance reporting.

However, calculating ultimate breakage, establishing incrementality, and determining accounting liabilities may require additional analysis and professional judgment.

The goal is not simply to maximize breakage or redemption.

It is to design a loyalty program that delivers meaningful customer benefits while supporting sustainable, measurable business performance.

Brands looking to improve loyalty analytics can explore Rivo's reporting and retention capabilities for Shopify merchants.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a good breakage rate for a loyalty program?

There is no universal good breakage rate. Published figures vary widely by industry, program structure, expiration policy, and measurement method. A more reliable approach is to compare the program's own historical breakage estimates and matured-cohort outcomes over time, using consistent definitions and observation periods.

What is the difference between breakage and redemption rate?

Breakage represents the share of a defined reward population that will never be redeemed, while redemption measures rewards that customers use. Ultimate breakage and ultimate redemption rates are complements when calculated for the same fully resolved cohort. Rolling redemption activity ratios, however, use different measurement periods and should not be treated as the direct opposite of ultimate breakage.

Are unredeemed loyalty points a liability?

Unredeemed loyalty points may create accounting obligations, but the treatment depends on the program. When points provide a material right under ASC 606 or IFRS 15, part of the transaction consideration is generally allocated to that obligation and deferred. Outstanding points and expected reward costs should not automatically be equated with the financial-statement liability.

How are loyalty points accounted for under ASC 606?

When loyalty points provide a material right, the entity generally allocates part of the transaction price to that performance obligation using relative standalone selling prices. Revenue is then recognized as the obligation is satisfied, with expected breakage treated according to the applicable guidance. The amount recorded may differ from a simplified expected reward-cost calculation.

Should promotional points be included in breakage calculations?

Promotional points can be included when the reporting scope is clearly defined, but they should generally be tracked separately from ordinary purchase-earned points as well. Promotional points may have different expiration periods, redemption requirements, and customer behaviors, which can make combined figures difficult to interpret.

Unlock retention secrets
Discover the latest in customer retention strategies and loyalty program innovations with our expert insights.
Subscribe
By clicking Sign Up you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Share this article:
Talk to a retention expert
Request a demo to chat with someone from Rivo.
Request a demo
Customer Retention Rate =
# of customers at the end of period -
# of customers acquired during period

_________________________

‍
# of customers at the start ofperiod
x 100
Loyalty is hard. Rivo makes it easy.
Install and get started for free, or request a demo to chat with someone from for 30-45 minutes.
Request a demo
Get retention insights
Built for ecommerce teams focused on long-term growth and repeat revenue.
Subscribe
By clicking subscribe you're confirming that you agree to receive occasional emails from Rivo
Thank you! You're subscribed to the Rivo newsletter.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.